Prefacing his unorthodox documentary as a meditation in self-indulgence, Casey Affleck captures the zeitgeist in a movie that is strictly that. Hoax or not, in 2008 the double Oscar nominated Joaquin Phoenix decided to pack up acting and turn to hip-hop as means for a career, giving up his sanity and civility along with it. Affleck, who happens to be Phoenix’s brother-in-law documents the entire trainwreck in what turns out to be a more probable telling of the demise of Jim Morrison than Oliver Stone’s adaptation in The Doors (1991). Becoming a reality-star outside the guise of a reality show, Phoenix still acts an apathetic prick on Letterman, punches a fan at his own rap show in Miami, and snorts coke off a hooker’s tit. Whether a fictive character or not, these are not fictive incidents and their effects rippled through the press. Nauseating movie-goers feel the film nullified simply because a 2010 clean-shaven and seemingly logic stricken Phoenix told audiences his 2008 persona was a joke, however this does not subtract from the message of the film. If anything, it augments a reality-crazed time when Jersey Shore and I Love New York are cable’s top billing.
Acting sheepish and self-effacing around his professional peers, when in close quarters with his seemingly delicate inner-circle, Phoenix shreds them apart taking out all his accumulated stress and pressure on to the only people there to help him. Audiences can thank Affleck for this mindful manipulation, which deems results better than any reality star could dream for. If this was a show on cable, it would finally surmount to more viewers than the beloved New York and Jersey combined. After defacing his closest friend to the point of public scrutiny, he retaliates by defecating on Phoenix’s head. This is one of many stones on the rock bottom hit by Phoenix in this sentimental journey through an A-list celebrities downfall.
What makes the movie worth watching though is Phoenix’s analysis of himself and his breakdown. Almost predicting his future Aldous Huxley in a essay on leisure stated “the majority of human beings can hardly fail to devote their leisure to occupations which, if not positively vicious, are at least stupid, futile and, what is worse, secretly realized to be futile.” Phoenix’s self-analysis of his futility is by far the greatest quality of the film. Figuring out his place in society, and his inescapable career as a puppet leads him to vomit, rage, and even make snow angels. Despite this bump in the road, Phoenix remains one of the finest actors in cinema and deserves an Oscar nod for this performance.